When we design an email journey, we tend to create something beautifully logical. Each email has a purpose, each message builds on the previous one, and every step moves the subscriber towards the outcome we want them to achieve. Email one introduces the proposition, email two explains the benefits, email three provides reassurance, email four introduces urgency, and email five encourages the final action. It’s a carefully considered sequence, supported by behavioural triggers, timing rules, and increasingly sophisticated automation.
There’s just one problem. Our subscribers haven’t agreed to follow the script.
They might skim the first email, ignore the second, read half of the third, and never see the fourth. They might disappear for two weeks, return through Google, and purchase without ever clicking another email. Yet our journey continues as though everything is going according to plan.
This was the subject of a recent Validity State of Email Trends webinar, Skim, Skip, Return: AI Mapped Journeys and Real Human Attention, where I joined Danielle Gallant to explore the growing disconnect between the journeys marketers design and the way subscribers actually experience them. And it raises a question I believe deserves considerably more attention: what happens when the success of your email journey depends on subscribers experiencing it in a way they rarely do?
A Journey Map Is Not a Map of the Customer’s Experience
When we look at a journey in our marketing automation platform, we see a carefully constructed progression. We know which emails were sent, the timing between them, which behavioural conditions were met, and which branches a subscriber followed. What we don’t know with anything approaching the same certainty is what the subscriber actually experienced.
Did they notice the subject line? Did they read the email, or simply glance at the headline? Did they understand the offer? Did they remember it? Were they distracted halfway through? Even when we can observe an open or a click, we cannot assume the message was understood in the way we intended. And when there is no measurable engagement, we shouldn’t automatically conclude that nothing happened.
The distinction matters because we’re designing journeys based on a sequence of communications, while subscribers experience a series of disconnected moments of attention. Those two things are not necessarily the same, yet we often evaluate the success of our programmes as though they are.
In Validity’s Holiday 2026 Consumer Survey, 31% of respondents reported becoming more selective about which promotional emails they opened during the holiday season. Another 28% said they deleted emails without reading them, while 21% reported ignoring more emails. These findings specifically concern holiday email behaviour, but they highlight an issue that extends beyond seasonal campaigns.
We can control when an email arrives, but we cannot control whether, when, or how someone pays attention to it. And that should influence how we design the journey in the first place, rather than simply how we evaluate its performance afterwards.
The Problem With Writing Email Journeys Like Chapters in a Book
Consider a typical browse abandonment programme. The first email reminds someone about the product they viewed, the second provides additional information about its benefits, and the third introduces customer reviews or reassurance. The fourth might offer an incentive, while the fifth creates a sense of urgency. As a sequence, this makes perfect sense because each message builds on the one before it, gradually introducing additional reasons to purchase.
But suppose the subscriber ignores the first two messages and opens the third. Have we given them enough context to understand why they’re receiving it? Does it communicate the value of the product independently, or does it assume they’ve already absorbed the information presented in the previous emails?
Now imagine they only see the fifth email. Does the urgency make sense? Is the proposition immediately clear? Can they understand what they’re being encouraged to do without having read the preceding communications?
This is where the structure of a journey can begin to work against us. We’ve written the emails as chapters in a story, assuming the subscriber has read everything leading up to the current moment. But subscribers don’t necessarily experience email as a continuous narrative. They experience whichever parts of the story happen to attract their attention, and if our messaging depends on what came before, we risk losing the opportunity to influence them when they finally engage.
The issue isn’t simply whether an individual email is well written. It’s whether that email can do its job independently of the rest of the programme, while still contributing to the overall objective of the journey.
That doesn’t mean abandoning sequential storytelling or making every email repeat everything that came before. A well-designed journey should still have a strategic progression, with different messages addressing different customer needs. But that progression shouldn’t be so dependent on previous communications that missing one or two messages undermines the effectiveness of everything that follows.
Designing for Partial Attention
I’ve written and taught extensively about System 1 and System 2 thinking, and I believe this is another area where understanding how people process information becomes particularly valuable. We know that people don’t necessarily approach every email with the same level of attention or motivation, and that their willingness to engage with information can change according to their circumstances and needs.
Sometimes they’re processing information quickly, relying on familiar cues, recognisable patterns, and whatever immediately stands out. At other times, they’re more engaged, prepared to evaluate the details, compare alternatives, and consider a decision more carefully. Our emails need to accommodate both, rather than assuming everyone will approach the message with the same level of attention.
During the Validity webinar, we discussed the importance of what I call the five-second scan. If someone gives your email five seconds of attention, what do they understand? Can they immediately identify what the message is about, why it might matter to them, and what they can do next? If the answer is no, you’re depending on a level of attention the subscriber may never give you.
This doesn’t mean every email should be short. I’ve never subscribed to the idea that shorter emails are automatically more effective, because the length of an email tells us very little about how easy it is to process. What matters is how much effort someone needs to make to find the information that’s relevant to them, and whether the structure allows them to engage at their preferred level of detail.
Clear headings, meaningful subheadings, carefully prioritised content, and obvious calls to action help people navigate the message according to their needs. Someone who wants to make a quick decision should be able to identify the essential information without unnecessary effort, while someone who needs more detail should have the opportunity to explore further.
Crucially, important information shouldn’t depend on someone having read a previous email, and it should remain accessible when images are disabled. This is why I advocate keeping essential information in live text rather than relying exclusively on imagery. We’re not simply writing for people who read every word; we’re writing for people who may read only a fraction of what we send, and who may never see some of our communications at all.
Repetition Isn’t Necessarily a Bad Thing
One of the interesting consequences of this approach is that it challenges another assumption marketers frequently make. We often work hard to avoid repetition across an email sequence because we don’t want to tell subscribers something we’ve already told them. Instead, we want every email to introduce a new argument, a different benefit, or another reason to act.
And there’s nothing inherently wrong with that approach. But avoiding repetition only makes sense if we believe the subscriber has encountered and retained everything we’ve previously communicated, which, as we’ve established, is far from guaranteed.
What if that important benefit mentioned in email one was never seen? What if the customer reassurance included in email two was skimmed and forgotten? By deliberately avoiding that information in subsequent messages, we may be removing something the subscriber needs to make a decision, purely because we’ve already included it somewhere else in the programme.
This doesn’t mean sending the same email five times. It means recognising that some information deserves to be repeated because it remains relevant, regardless of where someone encounters the journey. An important benefit can be expressed through different examples, a core proposition can be reinforced through customer evidence, and an essential condition can be repeated whenever it affects the decision being requested.
For example, imagine the third email in a browse abandonment programme focuses on customer reviews. The headline might simply say ‘Still not convinced?’, which makes sense if the subscriber has read the previous messages explaining the product and its benefits. But for someone encountering this email for the first time, the context is missing. A headline that identifies the product and introduces the customer reviews, supported by a brief reminder of its principal benefit, would make the email more useful without changing its purpose or position in the sequence.
It’s a relatively small adjustment, but it removes an unnecessary dependency on earlier communications. The marketer hasn’t needed to redesign the journey, introduce another automation branch, or create an entirely new message. They’ve simply considered how the email would work for someone who hasn’t followed the intended sequence.
The creative execution can evolve without requiring the subscriber to remember everything that came before. In other words, repetition can provide continuity without creating dependency, and when we’re designing for partial attention, that distinction becomes particularly important.
The Missing Principle: Journey Resilience
I think we need to introduce another consideration into how we evaluate automated programmes: journey resilience. By this, I mean the ability of a journey to remain useful, understandable, and persuasive even when subscribers don’t experience every message in the intended order.
A resilient journey doesn’t require perfect attention to function. Each email contributes to the overall strategy, but it also provides sufficient context and value to stand on its own. That might mean briefly restating the core proposition, repeating an important benefit, or making the next action clear without assuming previous engagement.
It also means considering what happens when a subscriber returns after a period of inactivity or moves between channels. Someone who received three emails but then visits your website independently isn’t necessarily starting their decision-making process again. Equally, we can’t assume they remember the content of those emails, or that they were paying attention to them in the first place. We need to design around that uncertainty rather than build programmes that depend on a level of knowledge we cannot reliably establish.
Of course, there are practical limitations to what marketers can know and how much they can adapt their programmes. Even with sophisticated marketing automation and integrated customer data, we cannot reliably identify everything a subscriber has read, understood, or remembered. Nor can we expect every organisation to have the technology, resources, or data infrastructure needed to respond to every possible variation in customer behaviour.
But that’s precisely why journey resilience matters. We don’t need to know exactly which messages someone has read to design communications that accommodate the possibility they haven’t read them all. And we don’t necessarily need more complicated automation to achieve it. In many cases, it’s about making better decisions within the programmes and platforms we already have.
This is particularly important as AI becomes more involved in journey creation. AI can help us construct sophisticated sequences, define behavioural branches, and generate messages that appear to progress logically towards conversion. But unless we specifically ask it to consider interrupted attention and incomplete exposure, it can reproduce the same assumptions we’ve been making for years.
An AI tool can generate a perfectly coherent five-email sequence without challenging whether the subscriber needs to see all five messages for the sequence to make sense. The technology isn’t necessarily the problem; it’s the assumptions we’re asking it to work with. If we provide AI with a flawed understanding of how customers experience email, we shouldn’t be surprised when it produces a beautifully structured journey that perpetuates those same flaws.
We Need to Review the Journey, Not Just the Emails
Most email testing focuses on individual messages. We test subject lines, headlines, content, design, calls to action, and offers, assessing how each email performs and using those findings to improve subsequent campaigns. Yet how often do we consider whether an email journey still works when parts of it are missing?
This doesn’t require a separate optimisation project or a complete overhaul of an existing programme. It’s something we can incorporate into the way we already review and improve our automated journeys.
For example, when reviewing a welcome programme, we might consider whether the third email still makes sense to someone who hasn’t opened the first two. Does it clearly communicate why the message is relevant, or does it assume the subscriber has already learned something about the brand? Similarly, when optimising an abandoned browse sequence, we can consider whether the urgency in the final email is meaningful to someone who hasn’t engaged with the earlier messages.
Sometimes these considerations will lead to small changes in copy or content hierarchy. In other cases, they might reveal that an entire sequence is overly dependent on the subscriber following a particular path. Either way, the starting point is simply to consider the individual emails from the perspective of someone who may be encountering the message for the first time.
And this is where our normal testing and optimisation processes can help. Rather than making wholesale changes to the programme, we can test whether providing additional context, reinforcing a benefit, or clarifying the proposition improves the response to an individual email. Where volumes allow, we can assess those changes against the existing version, while also considering their contribution to the wider journey.
Importantly, we should be looking for improvements in meaningful customer and commercial outcomes, rather than assuming that an increase in opens or clicks necessarily indicates a better experience.
What matters is changing the question we’re asking. Instead of simply asking whether each email contributes to the journey, we should also ask whether it works without the journey. And if it doesn’t, we need to consider whether we’re expecting too much from subscribers who may never have encountered the information we’re assuming they already know.
Stop Mistaking the Journey We Measured for the Journey They Took
There’s one further implication worth considering. When our reporting shows that a subscriber converted after receiving email five, it’s tempting to interpret that conversion within the structure we’ve designed. We can see the sequence of sends, the recorded interactions, and the eventual outcome, which can create the impression that we understand how the subscriber reached their decision.
But that doesn’t mean we know which messages contributed to the decision, or how the subscriber experienced them. Perhaps the first email introduced an idea that stayed with them, while the third provided reassurance. Perhaps they only noticed the subject lines before returning through another channel, or perhaps something entirely unrelated to our email programme influenced their decision.
Our reporting can help us understand what happened within the parts of the journey we can observe, but it cannot reconstruct every moment of attention, memory, or influence that contributed to the outcome. That’s why I believe journey evaluation needs to extend beyond individual email engagement to consider the overall customer experience and commercial outcome.
Are subscribers progressing towards meaningful decisions? Is the programme helping them? Are we making it easier to act when they’re ready, or introducing unnecessary friction because our automation assumes they should be at a particular stage?
Those questions matter just as much as which email received the final click. After all, the purpose of an email journey isn’t to persuade subscribers to follow our carefully planned sequence. It’s to help them achieve an outcome that has value for them, while supporting our commercial objectives.
The Journey Should Adapt to the Human, Not the Other Way Around
We spend considerable time designing sophisticated customer journeys, and rightly so. Automation allows us to deliver timely, relevant communications at a scale that would otherwise be impossible, while creating opportunities to respond to customer behaviour in ways that simply weren’t feasible in the past.
But sophistication doesn’t necessarily mean we’ve designed something that reflects how people actually behave. A journey can be logically constructed, beautifully written, extensively tested, and technically flawless, yet still depend on an unrealistic expectation of subscriber attention.
People are busy, distracted, and often doing several things at once. They forget information, their priorities change, and they encounter communications in different places, at different times, and with different levels of interest. None of that is particularly surprising, yet we continue to design programmes that frequently assume a predictable progression from one carefully planned message to the next.
The encouraging thing is that accommodating this behaviour doesn’t necessarily mean adding complexity. We can begin by reconsidering the assumptions underlying the journeys we already have, making small but meaningful improvements as part of our existing optimisation activities, and recognising that each email may be someone’s first meaningful encounter with our message, regardless of where it sits in the sequence.
We don’t need subscribers to become more disciplined readers of our emails. We need to become better at designing journeys that accommodate the way they already behave, without sacrificing the strategic progression that makes automated programmes valuable in the first place.
Because ultimately, the most effective email journey isn’t necessarily the one with the most logical sequence. It’s the one that still works when the subscriber doesn’t follow it.
This article builds on a discussion with Danielle Gallant during Validity’s State of Email Trends webinar, Skim, Skip, Return: AI Mapped Journeys and Real Human Attention, held on 21 October 2026. The webinar recording is available on demand.
